1969: “St. Bonaventure parish, Cincinnati, will mark the 100th anniversary of its founding November 23 when Archbishop Paul F. Leibold and former pastors of the church will concelebrate Mass in the century-old church on Queen City Avenue.
“St. Bonaventure Church, begun in 1868 and dedicated Nov. 20, 1869, replaced an earlier church, St. Peter’s, which had been founded in 1844. Located on Lick Run Road (now Quebec Road) in South Fairmount, St. Peter’s served a small congregation in the valley between Fairmount and Price Hill. West of what was then the city of Cincinnati, the area sometimes was referred to as Petersburg.
”In 1866, Father Benjamin Mennchen, O.F.M., who as in charge of St. Peter’s and resided at St. Francis Church, Liberty and Vine streets, ‘resolved to build a new church,’ Father John H. Lamott reported in his History of the Archdiocese of Cincinnati, because the old church building was ‘going to ruins and situated at an inconvenient place.’
“Work was begun in 1868 and the cornerstone was blessed on Sept. 6. The Catholic Telegraph reported on Sept. 9, 1868:
“Last Sunday afternoon many thousands of Catholics, in and out of procession, attended the placing of the cornerstone of the new church of St. Bonaventure, at Fairmount, a near suburb of Cincinnati. The ceremony was performed by the Most Rev. Archbishop (John B.) Purcell . . .
“The day was most favorable and the order perfect. A handsome collection was taken up during the proceedings, in twelve cigar boxes, one of the best filled being the one taken around by an Irish Catholic Mr. Joyce.
“There were three or four tastefully festooned arches spanning the road, in the route of the procession, on which were inscribed in large letters, in German and English, ‘Welcome Brethren,’ ‘In Union There Is Strength.’ The brass bands heading the various societies, the Young Men’s Vocal Choir, and a brace of cannon discharged frequently at intervals during the march and the ceremonies, enlivened the scene.
“Dedication of the completed church took place Nov. 20, 1869. In the ensuing years it was enlarged and improved by the addition at various times of transept and sanctuary, sacristy, portico, retaining wall and tower clock. School buildings were erected at the two sides of the church in 1871 and 1892, but the two buildings are gone. With the growth of the parish a larger school was built in 1909. A convent for the teaching Sisters was added in 1923, and in 1926 a rectory and a new school building were erected.
“The first marriage in St. Bonaventure’s was that of John Merkel and Anna Schaeffler, on Dec. 5, 1869. First person to be baptized was Mary Ann Pfohl, daughter of Michael and Catherine Stier Pfohl, on Nov. 28, 1869.” (
See The Catholic Telegraph, November 13, 1969)
Note: St. Bonaventure closed its doors in 2003, uniting with nearby St. Leo the Great.